Reviews

timesofindia

July 7, 2014
4.0
A remake of the 2012-Malayalam film 22 Female Kottayam, Malini 22 Palayamkkottai turns what was a post modern revenge film (with a somewhat dubious women's lib credo) into a dated and tedious affair. Even if director Sripriya had stuck close to the original, we would have got an engaging thriller, but here, bludgeons even the tiniest bit of subtlety found in the original to give us a clumsy film that attempts to form a social awakening while putting its viewers to sleep. The film begins with Malini (a miscast Nithya Menen), a nurse at a private hospital, getting arrested for being in possession of drugs and her story until this point unfolds as flash back. We are introduced to her friends-cum-colleagues, one of whom, Jency ( Anjali Rao), acts as a 'companion' for an older man, in whose mansion they stay together. Malini is befriended by Varun (Krish Sathar, impressive), who facilitates her visa to Canada, and the two soon become romantically involved. When Jency goes to Canada, Malini is forced to stay with Varun. One day, during Varun's absence, his boss Prakash ( Naresh) enters their home and rapes her. Malini is shell-shocked while Varun is furious. As she limps back to normalcy, Prakash enters her life again, and rapes her again! And, worse, she is arrested for possession of drugs. Malini loses all hope but when she learns about the betrayal that has led her to this fate, she plans her revenge. Malini 22 Palayamkkottai is a very topical film, and it does have its heart in the right place but the problem with the film mostly lies with the direction, as Sripriya seems to lack a feel for the material. The filmmaking is tacky and at best TV serial-like. While this might not have felt out of place in an old-fashioned drama, here, it seems odd. Not only do the changes that she brings to this tale, in terms of characters and scenes (a needless fight inside the jail), add anything to the film, but they also feel frivolous. Take Kovai Sarala, who plays the heroine's colleague. She is loud, is needlessly made to blush before young men like the hero in the name of comedy and vanishes half way into the film! Even Jency is given a back story (she is the sole breadwinner for her large family) whereas in the original, was this character presented in a matter-of-fact way and we are never told why she does what she does. And, probably in an effort to make her heroine character more of a saint, the director does away with the character's admission of not being a virgin. It is a crucial point in the original because later in the film, when her character decides to do anything to get back at the persons responsible for her fate, we understand her readiness to compromise. It also underscored the point that she, a rape victim, has realized that it is her heart and not her body that needs to be pure. Another let down is the climatic scene in which the heroine Malini, who has turned from docile nurse to avenging angel, tells Varun, her boyfriend-turned-betrayer that he cannot mess up her life any more. She tells him that she thought about his punishment as his mother and sister and decided it was right to do what she had to do. Nithya Menen utters this dialogue in such a manner that it turns what should have been a biting comment into a melodramatic one. They then trade a few expletives (which are sensibly not muted) that should have been punches in the gut but what they really seem like is adolescents showing off their knowledge of cuss words. Which brings us to the question how did this film, which features rape, pre-marital sex, and the F-word (even if relevant to the story) manage to get a 'U' certificate, when, in the same week, we have another film (Ner Ethir), dealing with adultery, that is rated 'A'?

Recommendation Movies

7.1
Comedy
View
7.1
Soodhu Kavvum
Soodhu Kavvum2013
5.7
Romance
View
5.7
Rummy
Rummy2014
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
The Banshees of Inisherin
The Banshees of Inisherin2022
6
Romance
View
6
The Adventures
The Adventures2023
6.8
Crime
View
6.8
Strange Darling
Strange Darling2024
7.5
Thriller
View
7.5
Anatomy of a Fall
Anatomy of a Fall2023
7.1
Comedy
View
7.1
Miles and Lies
Miles and Lies2023
7.4
Romance
View
7.4
All of Us Strangers
All of Us Strangers2023
6.3
History
View
6.3
Napoleon
Napoleon2023
5.5
Drama
View
5.5
Joker: Folie à Deux
Joker: Folie à Deux2024
6.8
Action
View
6.8
The Roundup: Punishment
The Roundup: Punishment2024
7.5
Documentary
View
7.5
The Menendez Brothers
The Menendez Brothers2024
6.1
Action
View
6.1
Lesson Plan
Lesson Plan2022
7.3
Thriller
View
7.3
The Last Client
The Last Client2022
7
Drama
View
7
The Zone of Interest
The Zone of Interest2023
6.9
Old Man Junior
Old Man Junior2024
5.7
Horror
View
5.7
The Passenger
The Passenger2022
6.3
Action
View
6.3
Cash Out
Cash Out2024
7
Drama
View
7
A
A2017
7.5
Action
View
7.5
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga2024
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt