Reviews

CRCulver

August 14, 2018
5.0
In Abbas Kiarostami's 1997 film Ta'm-e gilas (Taste of Cherry) one Mr. Badi, a man about whom viewers learn virtually nothing, drives around Tehran looking for someone to do him a favour: that night, he will kill himself in a quarry outside the city, and he wants someone to cast dirt over his body the next morning. The first half of the film is essentially about Mr. Badi's difficulties finding someone to carry out this small task, in spite of the substantial amount of money he's offering. He is initially mistaken as a homosexual cruising for sex, a misunderstanding that Kiarostami even ribaldly encourages through suggestive dialogue. A seminary student refuses to help him because suicide is a sin. I must say that I was very disappointed by these 40 minutes plus. Shooting so much of the film inside the car as Mr. Badi drives around is a waste of the possibilities of cinema. Furthermore, there is no real rapport between Mr. Badi and the various actors, as it was originally Kiarostami sitting in the passenger seat, and the dialogue of the men Mr. Badi picks up was only dubbed in later. The film does largely rely on amateur actors, as is common in Iranian productions from this era. Mr. Badi is played by the architect Homayoun Ershadi, and though Ershadi eventually established a film career, this was his first role. The film does become stronger in the second half, when Kiarostami starts to move from the dusty and barren quarry to more lively scenery of inhabited Tehran, a clear metaphor for the joy and colour of life that Mr. Badi would be giving up if he went through with his plans. The film starts to be thought-provoking instead of merely awkward, and as a glance at discussion forums will show, the film does offer enough to keep cinephiles talking about it. Unfortunately, the ending that Kiarostami chose for the film (which I won't spoil here) feels to me like a cop-out, not to mention something that is already an old auteur trope by now. If you like the Iranian Second Wave, then you'll probably find it worthwhile to see Ta'm-e gilas at least once. However, in spite of its winning of the Palme d'Or, I do not feel this is an especially great film.

Recommendation Movies

7.9
Crime
View
7.9
Close-Up
Close-Up1990
7
Drama
View
7
Certified Copy
Certified Copy2010
7.9
Drama
View
7.9
Where Is The Friend's House?
Where Is The Friend's House?1987
7.1
War
View
7.1
The Red and the White
The Red and the White1967
6.1
Comedy
View
6.1
Hospitalité
Hospitalité2011
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
Final Cut: Ladies and Gentlemen
Final Cut: Ladies and Gentlemen2012
6
Drama
View
6
Shirin
Shirin2008
6.9
Drama
View
6.9
Pizza, Beer, and Cigarettes
Pizza, Beer, and Cigarettes1998
5.7
Crime
View
5.7
Jagame Thandhiram
Jagame Thandhiram2021
6.6
Drama
View
6.6
Dhobi Ghat
Dhobi Ghat2010
7
Documentary
View
7
Ai Weiwei: Never Sorry
Ai Weiwei: Never Sorry2012
6.3
Action
View
6.3
The Old Man and the Sea
The Old Man and the Sea1990
6.9
Drama
View
6.9
Atlantide
Atlantide2022
6.7
History
View
6.7
Viva l'Italia!
Viva l'Italia!1961
7.4
Drama
View
7.4
The White Balloon
The White Balloon1995
6.5
Documentary
View
6.5
Invisible Demons
Invisible Demons2021
6.5
Drama
View
6.5
The Bread and Alley
The Bread and Alley1970
5.6
Drama
View
5.6
Travelling Salesman
Travelling Salesman2012
5
Drama
View
5
Tinnitus
Tinnitus2023
5.1
Drama
View
5.1
We Still Have the Deep Black Night
We Still Have the Deep Black Night2019
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt