Reviews

tmdb28039023

August 27, 2022
4.0
Co-writers Ian McKellen and Richard Loncraine (who also directs) set their Richard III in 1930s Britain, and make the infamous hunchback a fascist warmonger plotting to usurp the throne. Today's English monarchy is, at best, nominal, but even way back in the 1930s there wasn't much to be gained by usurping it. Then again, the film takes place in an alternate reality where the War of the Roses occurs 450 years after the true historical conflict did. I don’t mind so much that royalty has endured those four centuries and a half; what does bother me is that language has not evolved in the interim at the same rate as, say, warfare. Why on Earth would Richard (McKellen), who is neither dumb nor crazy, use the expression “my kingdom for a horse” when he could be asking for a tank instead? This line is only in the movie because it’s in the play – but then, a great many things that are in the play aren’t in the film, and viceversa, so why keep this particular bit? I mean, it couldn’t be because the audience is expecting it, even though it makes zero sense given the circumstances, could it? Did they think diehard Shakespeare fans would riot otherwise? Well, if there were such a thing as hardcore Shake-heads, I assure you they would have rioted long before this point. Similarly outdated is a scene in which several characters who have been at each other’s throats are compelled to swear mutual oaths of loyalty. As Al Pacino’s superb documentary Looking for Richard rightly points out, at the time that the original play is set this would be serious business, because only people who want to go to hell would swear an oath and not keep it. Ditto the scene where Richard blames his deformity on Queen Elizabeth's witchcraft; this is an accusation that would have been given credence in the 1470s, but not so much in the 1930s. All things considered, it’s somewhat ironic that McKellen had a hand in the script, because his performance is worthy of much better material. His body language, in particular, is priceless – this Richard looks like a super-intelligent ape masquerading as a British Army field marshal. And when he breaks the fourth wall – another device that works better on a theater stage –, it feels as if Richard is letting the viewers in on that the entire movie is a sick joke he's playing on the other characters. If only.

Recommendation Movies

6.7
Documentary
View
6.7
Looking for Richard
Looking for Richard1996
6.5
Adventure
View
6.5
The Horseman on the Roof
The Horseman on the Roof1995
6.1
Family
View
6.1
Heavyweights
Heavyweights1995
5.9
Drama
View
5.9
Edmond
Edmond2005
5.5
Adventure
View
5.5
Into Thin Air: Death on Everest
Into Thin Air: Death on Everest1997
5
Drama
View
5
The Old Curiosity Shop
The Old Curiosity Shop2007
Hard Scrambled2006
8
Drama
View
8
To Live
To Live1994
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
My Dinner with Andre
My Dinner with Andre1981
7.3
Drama
View
7.3
Dead Man Walking
Dead Man Walking1995
6.7
Animation
View
6.7
An American Tail
An American Tail1986
6.9
Romance
View
6.9
Under the Tuscan Sun
Under the Tuscan Sun2003
6.6
Comedy
View
6.6
Sliding Doors
Sliding Doors1998
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
Thelma & Louise
Thelma & Louise1991
6.6
Action
View
6.6
Rambo
Rambo2008
6.7
Comedy
View
6.7
Logan Lucky
Logan Lucky2017
6.7
Animation
View
6.7
Rio
Rio2011
7.2
Adventure
View
7.2
Jumanji
Jumanji1995
7.4
Science Fiction
View
7.4
Star Trek
Star Trek2009
6.8
Horror
View
6.8
Bird Box
Bird Box2018
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt