Reviews
CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

February 8, 2024
7.0
I found there to be something of the beauty of one of novelist Rumor Godden's other novels - "Black Narcussus" (1947) in this gorgeously photographed tale of three young women growing up with the Ganges river providing a constant in their lives. Our story is narrated, in part, by "Harriet" (Patricia Walters) who lives an affluent life beside the river with her much younger sisters, brother and with her mother (Nora Swinburne) expecting number seven! The age difference means she spends much of her time with her two friends "Valerie" (Andrienne Corri) and "Melanie" (Radha). "Melanie" is of mixed-race, her father being being British, her late mother a local - and so their's is a more complex dynamic fitting in with a society that was still pretty unforgiving of inter-racial transgressions. The three girls rub along well enough though, enjoying the simplicities of their privileged lives, until the arrival of the handsome "Uncle John" (Thomas E. Breen) who is the cousin of "Mr. John" (Arthur Shields) - the dad of "Melanie". This visitor has, quite literally, been through the wars and has a prosthetic limb to show for it. Psychologically struggling, he has come to hide himself away; to remove any reminders of his former more able existence. What he doesn't bargain for though are these three girls. They take an immediate shine to him and over the course of the latter part of the film we enjoy their growing infatuation and rivalries - all set amidst the colourful and vibrant Hindu community in which they live but with which they have remarkably little but the most polite of involvement. As you'd expect, the narrative delivers an occasional tragedy and it takes a perhaps little too stoic a view on the value of human life - especially when it isn't white - but for the most part the story seems set on avoiding anything politically, or even societally contentious as the plot develops. Essentially, there's not a great deal of actual substance to this story. It's a beautifully photographed and aesthetically pleasing depiction of a dream, if you like - and it's not a great dream for everyone; even "Harriet" - before the timeless Ganges continues on it's way past farms, fields, temples and homes. It looks great on a big screen and if you can, literally, go with the flow then you ought to be able to appreciate it for what it was, when it was written in 1946.

Recommendation Movies

7.7
Drama
View
7.7
The Turin Horse
The Turin Horse2011
7.2
Drama
View
7.2
Shoot the Piano Player
Shoot the Piano Player1960
7.4
Drama
View
7.4
Shane
Shane1953
7.2
Drama
View
7.2
A Touch of Sin
A Touch of Sin2013
6.7
Comedy
View
6.7
The Seventh Company Outdoors
The Seventh Company Outdoors1977
7.4
Documentary
View
7.4
Rain
Rain1929
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
The Earrings of Madame de...
The Earrings of Madame de...1953
6.2
Drama
View
6.2
The Headless Woman
The Headless Woman2008
7.1
Comedy
View
7.1
The Golden Coach
The Golden Coach1952
6.2
Drama
View
6.2
By the Time It Gets Dark
By the Time It Gets Dark2016
6.9
Drama
View
6.9
The Brute
The Brute1953
8
Drama
View
8
The Wages of Fear
The Wages of Fear1953
7.1
Drama
View
7.1
Downton Abbey
Downton Abbey2019
7.8
Animation
View
7.8
Paprika
Paprika2006
8.2
Thriller
View
8.2
The Handmaiden
The Handmaiden2016
8.2
Horror
View
8.2
The Shining
The Shining1980
8.1
Crime
View
8.1
Joker
Joker2019
7.1
Adventure
View
7.1
The Lion King
The Lion King2019
8.5
Comedy
View
8.5
Parasite
Parasite2019
7.6
Family
View
7.6
The Super Mario Bros. Movie
The Super Mario Bros. Movie2023
© 2025 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt