Reviews

tmdb28039023

August 28, 2022
1.0
J.D. Salinger didn’t write to be read – or seen. The author of The Catcher in the Rye stopped publishing in 1965 – but continued writing until his death 45 years later –, and long before that he had made up his mind to refuse to allow film adaptations of his work (a non-acceptance that has miraculously survived him). As a result, the lazy and the uncreative have had to find alternative avenues for profiting from Salinger's work. The most recent example of this is My Salinger Year, a drama written and directed by Philippe Falardeau, based on Joanna Rakoff's memoir of the same name. In 1995, Joanna (Margaret Qualley), an aspiring writer and poet, moves to New York, where she gets a job at one of New York's oldest literary agencies. Unbeknownst to Joanna, the agency looks after the interests of notoriously reclusive writer J. D. Salinger (additionally, she moves into an apartment with her new boyfriend, who is writing a novel, which, when finished, fits perfectly inside a thin manila envelope; I’d venture that perhaps the envelope contains a flash drive with the book in it, but this is the mid-90s, after all). Joanna's duties include responding to Salinger's voluminous fan mail. According to agency policy, Joanna replies with a generic formula explaining that Salinger does not read fan letters (and if the letters were anything like the ones in the movie, he wasn't missing much – and neither were we). She, however, becomes tempted to write back something with a little more substance to certain Salinger fans – though not having read any of his work (not even Catcher), it’s hard to tell what led her to believe she was qualified to become Salinger’s self-appointed mouthpiece. The only reason the writer's last name appears in the title of this movie is to lure unsuspecting viewers into watching it in hopes of learning something valuable about Salinger. As it turns out, though, the plot has little or nothing to do with the author (and it isn’t even clever enough to be a pastiche like Igby Goes Down) except a perverse eagerness to pry into and exploit his two most valued possessions: his privacy and his art. Consider this: in May 1986, Salinger discovered that British writer Ian Hamilton intended to publish a biography that made extensive use of letters Salinger had written to other authors and friends. Salinger sued to stop publication of the book, and in Salinger v. Random House, the court ruled that Hamilton's extensive use of the letters, including quoting and paraphrasing, was not acceptable as the author's right to control publication overrode the right of fair use. It doesn't take a genius to conclude that Salinger wouldn't be much happier with a book and film based on correspondence that he didn't read – let alone replied to –, starring a character who has deliberately avoided the author’s oeuvre, because she wants to be “provoked,” not “entertained.” All things considered, My Salinger Year is neither provocative nor entertaining.

Recommendation Movies

5.4
Drama
View
5.4
Amnesia
Amnesia2015
10
Drama
View
10
Revolta dos Malês
Revolta dos Malês2023
0
Adventure
View
0
Shackleton
5.6
Drama
View
5.6
To Whom It May Concern
To Whom It May Concern2015
6.1
Action
View
6.1
Big Trouble
Big Trouble2002
5.6
Comedy
View
5.6
The Four of Us
The Four of Us2021
6
Thriller
View
6
Strange but True
Strange but True2019
6.8
Drama
View
6.8
With a Friend Like Harry...
With a Friend Like Harry...2000
6.5
Comedy
View
6.5
A Good Doctor
A Good Doctor2019
5.4
Comedy
View
5.4
The Palace
The Palace2023
6.7
Comedy
View
6.7
The Beautician and the Beast
The Beautician and the Beast1997
5.9
Comedy
View
5.9
You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger
You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger2010
7.2
Drama
View
7.2
Happening
Happening2021
6.3
Crime
View
6.3
No Sudden Move
No Sudden Move2021
7.6
War
View
7.6
Persian Lessons
Persian Lessons2020
7.2
Animation
View
7.2
Jack and the Cuckoo-Clock Heart
Jack and the Cuckoo-Clock Heart2014
6.9
Adventure
View
6.9
Holes
Holes2003
7.4
Comedy
View
7.4
La Belle Époque
La Belle Époque2019
7.4
Comedy
View
7.4
Those Happy Days
Those Happy Days2006
7
Comedy
View
7
Rose Island
Rose Island2020
© 2025 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt