Reviews

MovieGuys

August 5, 2023
4.0
The best way I can describe this effort is a contemporised, misinterpretation, of Dumas novel. If, like me, you have read The Three Musketeers novel, more than once, you'll find this film largely divorced, from that work. The inconsistencies are glaring. The most obvious is steering this tale away from its focus on the male leads, in favour of not necessarily peripheral but definitely secondary or tertiary, female characters. Yes, in my opinion, its yet another clumsy chance to hoist the flag of feminism. Making female characters relevant to the story, in the modern woke context. Of course, this predictably, unbalances the story. The musketeers, are, nudged into the background, in the own tale. The second point of failure is the age of D'Artagnan, who in past films is typically played by a young male actor because this tale, in a sense, is a coming of age story. That's all swept aside too, quite possibly in service to the feminisation of the story.Instead, he's portrayed by a 33 year old man, incongruously called, "a boy". Suffice to say, it all feels rather awkward. Are there any redeeming elements to the production? Obviously, the acting is sound, its a strong cast. Money has been spent on sets, settings, fight choreography and more, to try to bring this period in French history, to life. Regrettably, so much else is wrong that this film simply feels "openly fake", to this reviewer. I do not see it as a loyal expression, of Dumas sterling work. Nor the period, in which it is set. In summary,feminises an essentially masculine tale. Don't believe me, just look at the poster, not to mention the film itself. In my view there are numerous superior and more accurate, cinematic expressions of Dumas work, on offer.

Recommendation Movies

6.4
Adventure
View
6.4
The Three Musketeers: Milady
The Three Musketeers: Milady2023
6.4
Drama
View
6.4
On the Wandering Paths
On the Wandering Paths2023
8
Drama
View
8
All Your Faces
All Your Faces2023
5.8
Crime
View
5.8
Marlowe
Marlowe2023
6
Comedy
View
6
The King of Algiers
The King of Algiers2023
6.7
History
View
6.7
Abbé Pierre - A Century of Devotion
Abbé Pierre - A Century of Devotion2023
6.5
Comedy
View
6.5
The Lost King
The Lost King2022
6.5
Drama
View
6.5
Hokusai
Hokusai2021
7
Drama
View
7
Jeanne du Barry
Jeanne du Barry2023
7.1
Comedy
View
7.1
Sage homme
Sage homme2023
7.1
Drama
View
7.1
Junkyard Dog
Junkyard Dog2023
7
Crime
View
7
November
November2022
8
Animation
View
8
Suzume
Suzume2022
8.3
Adventure
View
8.3
The Count of Monte-Cristo
The Count of Monte-Cristo2024
6.7
Drama
View
6.7
The Son
The Son2022
6.5
Comedy
View
6.5
Alibi.com 2
Alibi.com 22023
6
Comedy
View
6
Bonne Conduite
Bonne Conduite2023
6.3
Drama
View
6.3
Everybody Loves Jeanne
Everybody Loves Jeanne2022
7.3
Drama
View
7.3
The Blue Caftan
The Blue Caftan2023
7.4
Thriller
View
7.4
Remember
Remember2022
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt