Reviews
CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

November 17, 2022
6.0
Film director Jafar Panahi is prohibited from leaving Iran, but is trying to make a film in neighbouring Turkey. In order to make that work, he moves to a remote village near the border, where the communications are a bit hit and miss. With the help of his obliging host "Ghanbar" (Vahid Mobaseri), though, he tries to make the best of it. Initially, it's a friendly village but when he takes (or doesn't!) a photograph of a young couple, he finds himself drawn into an increasingly acrid stand-off between two young men, and their families, to whom a girl may have been betrothed when her umbilical cord was cut. His frustrations with these encroachments are not helped by production difficulties with the two two stars of his documentary-style film - real life lovers who are trying to find a way to escape, safely, to Paris. There is the slightest hint of menace here as the plot develops and although we see little actual evidence, there is a distinct sense that this man is increasingly unwelcome, despite the platitudes from the villagers, encouraging a sixth-sense feeling that the authorities are distantly watching this film-maker. There is a distinct perception of intimidation! What is also clear is that these ordinary Iranian people live in fear of the police, the Revolutionary guard and that rather flies in the face of their genuine, peaceable and hospitable, nature. Now, perhaps Panahi's less-is-more style works for some, but for me I found this all rather a slow watch. He shuffles around with little useful dialogue to develop his on-screen persona, nor my interest in him. Clearly this is a story about freedom and a sort of subliminal oppression but somehow the characters themselves here didn't really develop that theme sufficiently, nor did they really engage me. The ending, too, is disappointing and inconclusive in equal measure and I was rather underwhelmed. The film does offer us an interesting depiction of rural life that probably hasn't changed in millennia, but somehow I felt little better than a fly on the wall with nowhere near enough to go on to join in. Perhaps just too much of this is predicated on a knowledge by the audience of this director and of his relationship with his government.

Recommendation Movies

6.3
Drama
View
6.3
Valeria Is Getting Married
Valeria Is Getting Married2023
8
Documentary
View
8
On Our Doorstep
On Our Doorstep2023
7
Drama
View
7
When It Melts
When It Melts2023
7.1
Comedy
View
7.1
The Idol
The Idol2016
6.8
Drama
View
6.8
Tori and Lokita
Tori and Lokita2022
6.8
Drama
View
6.8
3 Faces
3 Faces2018
6.4
Drama
View
6.4
Our Ties
Our Ties2022
7.5
Drama
View
7.5
Slap the Monster on Page One
Slap the Monster on Page One1972
6.6
Comedy
View
6.6
Kitchen Brigade
Kitchen Brigade2022
5.8
Thriller
View
5.8
I Am the Abyss
I Am the Abyss2022
7
Drama
View
7
Long Day's Journey into Night
Long Day's Journey into Night2018
7
Drama
View
7
Godland
Godland2022
6.9
Comedy
View
6.9
Cemetery Man
Cemetery Man1994
6.6
Drama
View
6.6
Notre-Dame on Fire
Notre-Dame on Fire2022
7.6
Action
View
7.6
Unicorn Wars
Unicorn Wars2022
7.4
Drama
View
7.4
Belle de Jour
Belle de Jour1967
7.6
War
View
7.6
Persian Lessons
Persian Lessons2020
7.1
Drama
View
7.1
Broker
Broker2022
7.2
Comedy
View
7.2
Shiva Baby
Shiva Baby2021
7.9
Mystery
View
7.9
Rebecca
Rebecca1940
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt