Reviews

Brent Marchant

October 31, 2024
6.0
It’s more than a little frustrating when a film seemingly has all of the elements needed to make it work except the one that’s most crucial, the one that enables a production to brilliantly succeed or doom it to failure – the story. Such is the case with director Edward Berger’s latest, the much-anticipated, much-celebrated drama about the convening of a papal conclave to select a new pope. From a technical standpoint, the filmmaker has pulled together everything that should make this an epic picture – a gorgeous production design, stunning and inventive cinematography, and a stellar cast featuring superb performances by the likes of Ralph Fiennes, Stanley Tucci, John Lithgow and Isabella Rossellini, as well as fine turns by such lesser-known performers (at least to American audiences) as Lucian Msamati and Sergio Castellito. The picture also raises some insightful observations (though a little too infrequently for my tastes) about the current state of the Roman Catholic Church, particularly its foot-dragging on implementing reforms, the incessant high-profile scandals that have rocked the institution, and the rising tide of unflattering public perceptions among its increasingly skeptical practitioners, all of which weigh heavily on the College of Cardinals in determining who should be named as the new Holy Father. Unfortunately, though, the story and script leave a lot to be desired. For starters, much of the film’s opening act moves by at a glacial pace, frequently causing one’s eyelids to become more than a little heavy. As the picture moves into the meat of the story – the conclave itself – it waxes somewhat melodramatic, not unlike a glorified 1980s prime time TV soap opera. Its attempt to come across as an intrigue-laced thriller amounts to more than a succession of backstabbing segments in which the leading candidates to become the next pontiff are systematically eliminated through the revelation of skeletons in their respective closets. Finally, as the movie enters the stretch run, it throws in several twists and turns that either come completely out of left field (and somewhat implausibly at that) or that predictably materialize on cue thanks to the planting of patently obvious clues early on that were wholly impossible to ignore as the story plays out. Regrettably, these narrative foibles undermine all of the other fine attributes that this production has going for it, ultimately amounting to a case of being long on style but a little skimpy on substance, a shortcoming that also plagued Berger’s last feature outing, “All Quiet on the Western Front” (2022). Unlike many others who have been so profoundly moved and thoroughly captivated by this release, perhaps my not having been born and raised Roman Catholic has somehow prevented me from fully appreciating the depth and magnitude accorded to this offering’s contents. But, as someone who seeks to evaluate everything I screen on an equal footing, I can’t help but observe that “Conclave” simply doesn’t measure up when it comes to what it takes to make a genuine big screen epic.

Recommendation Movies

5
Thriller
View
5
Magpie
Magpie2024
6.8
Comedy
View
6.8
Samer & Shaher & Baher
Samer & Shaher & Baher2010
5.8
Drama
View
5.8
Terminal
Terminal2015
5.5
Documentary
View
5.5
12
122020
7.8
Fantasy
View
7.8
Avengers from Hell
Avengers from Hell1981
5.9
Drama
View
5.9
Gunpowder
Gunpowder1985
8.3
Drama
View
8.3
LE CASO MIRASSOL 2
LE CASO MIRASSOL 22023
10
Documentary
View
10
Kopfleuchten
Kopfleuchten1998
5.7
False Start2006
6.3
Comedy
View
6.3
What Happens In Your Brain If You See a German Word Like...?
What Happens In Your Brain If You See a German Word Like...?2015
Ratas de alcantarilla2003
4
Thriller
View
4
The Killer Within Me
The Killer Within Me2003
6.7
Comedy
View
6.7
Nasib Do Re Mi
Nasib Do Re Mi1966
7
Romance
View
7
Love the Healing Power
Love the Healing Power2012
8
Music
View
8
R. Strauss: Der Rosenkavalier (Salzburger Festspiele)
R. Strauss: Der Rosenkavalier (Salzburger Festspiele)2014
10
Riverside: Anno Domini High Definition Bonus DVD 'Live in Amsterdam 2008'
Riverside: Anno Domini High Definition Bonus DVD 'Live in Amsterdam 2008'2009
5.3
Documentary
View
5.3
Palace of Electricity1900
5
Action
View
5
People in the Ocean
People in the Ocean1980
© 2024 MoovieTime. All rights reserved.Made with Nuxt